The Admiral's Daughter

 The Admiral’s Daughter: A Frontier Secret

About ten or so years ago as part of a larger project I wanted to work on showing how Americans all have connections to the most heroic and ordinary people in our nation's history. For every Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton there is a brother like Billy and Roger. The profound and the profane and most of the time a little bit of both, exist in each of us.

The saying that history is written by the winners is often misunderstood. It's not that the actual victors write down history, it's more akin to everyone being the hero of their own life story. It’s the central irony of how the United Daughters of the Confederacy spun their revisionist history in the Lost Cause Myth. What I think is implied but unsaid, is that the truths are preserved in the silences of the less popular aspects of the archives.  Which leads me to my own family mystery. For two and a half centuries, naval history has leaned on a genteel legend to explain why John Paul—a low-born Scottish captain fleeing from a murder beef—suddenly re-emerges in 1775 as the newly minted “John Paul Jones.”

The popular fiction credits a brief inland visit with a North Carolina politician, Willie Jones. It is a tidy story but it collapses under scrutiny. As I dug around in the records (and compared DNA matches) I found a much more likely scenario in the existence of an unacknowledged daughter born to our nation's original swashbuckling naval hero and his girlfriend Virginia blue blood, Dorothea Spotswood Dandridge. Having more than a few African American ancestors who would eventually “pass” and go from being black to white on the census there is irony in the name being more famously known for actress and Carmen Jones star Dorothy Dandridge.

Their daughter was named Ellen Jones (my dad’s great-great grandmother, 1776–1847) and she was born on the eve of the revolution. As you peel back the layers you find a scaffolding of protective legends managed by some of the architects of our Republic that provided a much less scandalous history for her.  Even so, Ellen’s bloodline would go on to spawn some of the most privileged, creative, eccentric but also salt of the Earth folks on the American frontier—hidden in plain sight. 

The Tinderbox: Hanover County, Virginia 1774–1775

In December 1773, after killing a mutinous crew member in Tobago, John Paul abandoned his ship and assumed the camouflage of a new name "John Jones." During these "lost years," he navigated two worlds: the unmonitored coastal channels of North Carolina and the elite planter society of Virginia.

In 1774, he was sheltered by Dr. John K. Read, a physician and nephew-in-law to Benjamin Franklin. Read’s estate bordered the plantation lands of Hanover County, the epicenter of Virginian aristocracy as well as both revolutionary and loyalist sentiment. Here, the rough-hewn Scottish captain crossed paths with Dorothea. She was the archetypal southern Belle: granddaughter of Royal Governor Alexander Spotswood and first cousin to Martha Dandridge Custis Washington. Dorthea’s mother died in late 1773 and at the same time her home was a frantic hub of pre-revolutionary activity. In 1774/75, 17-year-old Dorothea entered a clandestine romance with the fugitive captain.

The correspondence between Dr. Read and John Paul Jones in 1778 confirm the intensity of this affair, with Read noting that Dorothea’s father, Nathaniel West Dandridge, had "used every means in his power to prevent her from thinking of you."

The stakes were existential. By 1775, Dorothea’s cousin, George Washington, was Commander-in-Chief. An out-of-wedlock pregnancy between a high-society lady and a murderer would have caused a social disaster to the Dandridges and would have been a propaganda win for the Redcoats. When Ellen was born in 1776, she was scrubbed from public registries. The baby had to vanish because what would the neighbors think?. The keepers of this fiction were well known in their own right: Patrick Henry, Thomas Jefferson, and Joseph Hewes.

Upon further digging, I found out that to fix the problem, a scheme was hatched. In 1777, Virginia Governor Patrick Henry—a very close friend to Dorothea’s father—married the much younger Dorothea. This union provided the ultimate political shield. While Dorothea went on to raise Henry’s eight children from his first marriage, she also had eleven children with Henry. The young Ellen was quietly moved into the family of her maternal grandmother, the Spotswoods.

Simultaneously, Thomas Jefferson and Joseph Hewes—the strategists behind the Continental Marine Committee—were structuring the U.S. Navy around Jones, him being the colony’s ablest seaman. Jefferson, who was as skilled with diplomacy as he was discreet, and Hewes, who controlled a massive shipping network, had both motive and the means to keep the child hidden.

In 1798, Ellen Jones married Andrew Wallace (my dad’s great-great grandfather, 1778 -1826) in Carlisle, Pennsylvania. 

The Ghost in the Archives: The Code of "The Niece"

Ellen Jones Wallace spent her early married life in Troy, Ohio, before settling in Indiana, where she passed away in 1847. She exists in the margins of the archives—no birth records, no siblings. Yet, the oral history passed down to her grandson, Union General and author Lew Wallace, serves as a map that outlines the broader themes of the story. She claimed to be "from Virginia" and held a vivid memory of being "bounced on George Washington's knee"—a detail unlikely for a frontier orphan, but completely in line with being Martha Washington's cousin. She also claimed that she didn’t want to talk about the Revolutionary War because her “brother” died in the Battle of Brandywine.  This perfectly matches with a very famous story that happened to her first cousins Alexander and John Spotswood.  

Most tellingly, she claimed to be John Paul Jones’s "niece." In the 18th century, "niece" was the standard euphemism used to provide for an illegitimate child without validating a legal claim to titles. Modern genealogy has confirmed the truth: she was his daughter.

The Metric of Privilege: Elite Advancement

The truest measure of Ellen’s parentage are the privileges bestowed upon her children. In the 19th-century West, climbing from a frontier farm to the highest echelons of national power required immense political leverage.

• David Jones Wallace (1799–1859): Given a coveted West Point appointment meant for William Henry Harrison’s own son. He went on to become Governor of Indiana and a U.S. Congressman. His son, Lew Wallace, became a Civil War General and authored Ben-Hur, among other notable things.  Another son, William, was President Benjamin Harrison’s law partner. 

• William Henson Wallace (1811–1879): Governor of both the Washington and Idaho Territories and an intimate confidant of Abraham Lincoln.

• Catherine Wallace (1802–1859): Wed into the family of Revolutionary War hero Andrew Lewis at the age of 16.

• Benjamin Franklin Wallace (1804-1887): Built the legislative scaffolding, moving from the Indiana Senate to pioneer the Iowa Territorial Council.

• John Thompson Wallace (my dad’s great-grandfather, 1806–1862?): Was nominated by the state of Indiana as a teenager to train as a midshipman in the US Navy. He served as a midshipman on the USS Constellation in the West Indies Squadron in 1826 and in 1827 he was a surveyor directly under Captain Melancthon Taylor Woolsey. Records of his life in the 1830s are non-existent.  He started a family and fathered four children in Indiana in the 1840s.  In 1849 he was asked to go out to Northern California, and spent the 1850s as the US Deputy Federal Surveyor in California, where he surveyed the lands around Santa Clara. In 1860, he returned to Indiana and enlisted with his two teenage sons in the Union army. He likely was a spy for the Union during this time, and disappeared sometime in 1862. He was never heard from again and a grave has never been found.  His life was a masterclass in operational security, often omitted from family records while performing sensitive assignments for the Republic.

Epilogue: The 1905 Unraveling

The generational transmission of this secret is only confirmed by the 1905 repatriation of John Paul Jones’s body from Paris. A contingent of Wallace grandsons formally petitioned the government to have the Admiral entombed in Indianapolis. Their argument? His remains belonged there because the "vast majority of John Paul Jones's living descendants" resided in Indiana. It was a public unveiling of the family secret that strangely didn’t raise any eyebrows.

While some of the evidence remains circumstantial—the support of my father’s DNA, the absence of records, and the uncanny political patronage of her children—the narrative holds together with unintended precision. Ellen Jones' history was recast from being a possible scandal to an uplifting tale of a bootstrapped, deeply American history. Her descendants didn't just witness the building of the frontier; they provided leadership.